You've made the decision to try online dating and it's time to start creating your profile. When you start building your profile, you'll notice on some sites there will. Keep your dating headlines catchy, not kitschy. So you've signed up for a dating site like PlentyOfFish, thought long and hard about your profile, and selected. A woman with pink nail polish writing dating profile headlines for her According to the popular dating site Zoosk, people who have more of.